Get a piece of the pie

One of our favorite places. So many choices. Everything is good. My favorite is the fried chicken. Always get the pies.

Best chicken livers I've ever tasted. Butterscotch pie 🥧 like grandmas. Couple hours away but will go back. Amazing.

Always delicious! Well worth the drive. Enjoyed the roast beef 😋 Good helpings. The Best Cherry Pie 😋

I've never had a bad experience. Variety and quality of food is top notch. Staff is professional and very helpful. Quick and clean service and atmosphere. Where I go when I want home style food. A+

This place is wonderful. We can't say enough good things about Grays. The quality is like home cooking and the prices won't break your budget. They have everything including the best and a wide selection of desserts. Sooo worth the trip. The employees were kind and courteous too. Kudos for running an excellent operation!

Fantastic cafeteria setup. I had the fried chicken, green beans and mashed potatoes. Don't worry, I didn't forget dessert and you shouldn't either. Fast, friendly, good. Entire family agrees we will be coming back here!

Pretty tasty drove from. Fishers to try their food. My husband has had it before and loves it. It was my birthday 🥳 and I wanted to try something different

Awesome food. I had the Roast Beef Manhattan corn casserole and veggies with cheese. For dessert I had the strawberry cheesecake. The food was phenomenal! The entire experience going into a place like a cafeteria brought back so many memories that you just don't get to experience as an adult. It was alot of fun!

I remember, whenever my mother had to go to Indianapolis, we had to stop at Gray Brothers. They never disappoint. The food is excellent and you'll have trouble picking out dessert. After more than 50 years it's still one of my favorites.

This place is a staple in the area for decades, great comfort food and atmosphere!

Made the trip for some Chicken livers, and strawberry cheesecake. Line was fast, and service very pleasant, as usual.

Good! Good! Good! Servings plentiful and price reflects the great food. The best cafeteria in Indiana.

Always outstanding food! Can't get anything better anywhere. The on problem you will have is deciding what to eat.

Always good food here! Something for everyone. They have everything from chicken strips to salmon. Great desserts and fresh veggies.

Very friendly staff, very clean roomy area. Clean seating & tables kept clean, drinks kept full. Bathrooms are clean, Good atmosphere, family room style. Not to pricey, good portions size. If you go away hungry, it's your fault. Will go back.

As usual, Gray Brothers didn't disappoint. Decided to celebrate my parents 47th wedding anniversary by eating dinner here. Food was amazing and the mac and cheese was super delicious!! I almost bought a pan to take with me.

We don't get here often, but it is worth the drive! The food choices are great and the food is always delicious. It can be on the pricey side, depending on your choices. However, if you leave hungry, it's on you as the portions are huge! Definitely put this on your to eat at list if you are in central Indiana.

Great food!!!! Definitely a hometown staple. The fried chicken is the best!!!! I could drink that white gravy lol a great place to go if you want quality food. And the pies yummy!!!!

Always loved and love this place. Catfish is always a go for me, and Lemon Meringue pie is a must 😋🙌👌😍

I haven't been here in years and travelled a bit to go back but well worth the trip. I had the all white chicken dinner with green beans, mashed potatoes, white gravy, Cole slaw and cherry pie! Chicken was very moist and tender with a light breading and everything tasted homemade and delicious! I felt bad, I'm not used to carrying cash so I didn't have tip for the server that made sure I was doing good at my table. Cannot wait till I get back again!!!

Good ol down home cooking since I was a young kid. The faces have changed over the years but they have maintained a great quality cuisine thrift the years. A cafeteria that is sure to have a meal you'd be thrilled to eat. If you're new to Gray's... well don't hesitate.. get in line and get ready to chow.

Always great food. Great fried chicken and desserts. Highly recommend

Quality food for decades. Prime rib was amazing with chicken livers, mac & cheese, green beans and a big piece of cherry pie

Great as usual. Everything was good. I had Beef Manhattan (usual). If it's not broke, don't try and fix it. Wife had the same. My daughter (30) had the salmon. She said it was very good. My son (7) and granddaughter (9) had fried shrimp and grandson (2) had mac and cheese. We all had strawberry pie. Delicious! Great food friendly people.

Excellent food! Best home cooking around!